Enterprise messenger with own server. Replacing Bingo's Chat for MyChat

Інтерфейс Bingo's Chat

Bingo’s Chat is a closed software for small local networks without the server. Each program is a client and server at the same time. Bingo’s Chat works via UDP (broadcast or multicast). All chat members are equal, and there is no rights system or restrictions.

Though the product itself is free, it has еру ability to buy the administrator rights for 1 thousand rubles ($15.40), or 600 rubles, as the price on the website differentiates on the same page:

Bingo's Chat prices

Developers do not sell keys anymore. There can be only one Administrator. The technology of Admin "importance" is bizarre.

Bingo’s Chat has not been updated since 2010.

The official forum does not work:

Bingo's Chat forum

The program has interesting features. For example, work with Text2Speech engine, bots, IRC support. However, IRC was removed in the last versions.

The review is written for the latest version available — Bingo’s Chat 1.6.10 from November 6, 2010. We compared it with a free version of MyChat enterprise messenger 7.6 from July 12, 2019. Also, we described Bingo’s Chat issues and explained why you should switch to MyChat.

  1. A brief review of Bingo's Chat issues
    1. Problems with the installer. No digital signature, UAC privileges
    2. No UNICODE support
    3. "Garbage" traffic; broadcast problems
    4. Security issues
    5. Bingos'Chat interface flaws
    6. Problems with inserting pictures in the chat
    7. Bingo’s Chat and Windows terminal server
  2. Comparison of Bingo's Chat and MyChat intraoffice messenger
  3. Recommendation for switching to MyChat

1. A brief review of Bingo's Chat issues

In general, this is a bunch of errors and flaws that are inherent for all abandoned projects. These are issues with UNICODE, absence of digital signatures, "garbage traffic", interface bugs, technology flaws, technical restrictions and other bugs that users of this software suffer from. With screenshots and detailed explanations.

1.1. Problems with the installer. No digital signature, UAC privileges

The installer setup file does not have a digital signature, and it requires elevated privileges to start:

UAC and Bingo's Chat

By default, Bingo’s Chat wants to install in Program Files, perhaps, that's why it requires elevated privileges. But the program can be installed in another folder as the installer allows doing so:

Installing Bingo's Chat

A bit strange, that a setup file and the application itself have the same names — BingoChat.exe.

The bad thing, that the program is also without digital signature. Most companies do not allow installing such software due to security policies.

1.2. No UNICODE support

Bingo's Chat can't work with UNICODE encodings. Messages will be messed up after you send them:

UNICODE and Bingo's Chat

Copying and pasting text from another software to Bingo's Chat works incorrectly. You won't be able to insert the text in English, not to mention hieroglyphs, etc.:

Bingo's Chat encodings

1.3. "Garbage" traffic, broadcast problems

The application was developed to work without the server, and your network will be filled with unnecessary broadcast traffic. More client applications, more "garbage":

Garbage traffic in Bingo's Chat

However, this is the least of the problems.

Another problem is that you can't work via the Internet. You can't link remote offices of your company, because Bingo has no one server, and it can't work behind the NAT and proxy. The only way in such a situation is VPN tunnels based on third-party services such as Hamachi or, for example, OpenVPN.

The third problem is the absence of proper administration. You won't have centralized storage for conversations, one system of rights and restrictions, users actions audit. Complete anarchy. It is not a problem for domestic networks, but it is for business.

1.4. Security issues

Because the chat uses broadcasts (moreover, by default, UDP Broadcast goes on, not IP Multicast), the data often broadcasted for the whole network, not a specific recipient. It means messages can get into the wrong hands.

Nothing is clear about message encryption. No information neither in the Help nor on the website.

All conversations are not encrypted and stored for the public access in the folder C:\Program Files (x86)\Bingo's Soft\Bingo's Chat\Logs

The program's EXE-file is compressed by EXE compressor Petite, and require more memory consumption for its start.

Bingo’s Chat launches own HTTP-server on the port 1233, where all files you have ever sent are in a public domain:

https сервер Bingo's chat

A link at the bottom of the screen (http://bingosoft.info/en/page/bingos-chat/) goes nowhere:

Corrupted link in Bingo's Chat

1.5. Bingos'Chat interface flaws

The history does not load after restart (but it exists):

Bingo's Chat history

During the attempt of choosing a file on a network disk:

Bingo's Chat error

"Make ScreenSnap" does not work:

Screenshot tool for Bingo's Chat

No control for dates boundary values:

Control for boundary values in Bingo's Chat

The skin switches one to another sometimes in data request windows:

Bingo's Chat skins

Weird things happen for messages that described nowhere:

Messed up messages in Bingo's Chat

If you press the button "Insert link" (Alt+L), you can see the following:

Inserting links Bingo's Chat

There are empty lines in the program which painted in black and which purpose is unknown:

Black lines in Bingo's Chat

The system for configuring hotkeys does not control duplicates and does not allow using buttons "Shift" and "Win" for combinations:

Hotkeys Bingo's Chat

1.6. Problems with inserting pictures in the chat

If you insert a picture, then the interface of the main window gets "broken":

Inserting pictures Bingo's Chat

Moreover, window minimizing/maximizing does not help:

It is impossible to insert PNG file, but if you write the mask *.png manually in the inserting window then it works out. However, after inserting a picture, it starts blinking a couple of times per second. Why this happens is unclear:

Inserting picture in Bingo's Chat

If you insert a picture in the chat (from the clipboard using F3 of from a file), then no message window scrolling happens. But if you write a simple text — everything is okay.

1.7. Bingo’s Chat and Windows terminal server

A lot of companies use Windows terminal server for their employees' work. Unfortunately, Bingo’s Chat was not able to launch in a terminal environment because of two problems.

Firstly, the application takes the same ports for its work (they can be configured for each user individually).

Secondly, the program does not distinguish configuration for users' personal profiles. You have to install as many chat copies as many terminal users you have. Though the update question is not relevant as there are no new versions.

2. Comparison of Bingo's Chat and MyChat intraoffice messenger

In the table below we compare basic abilities of Bingo’s Chat 1.6.10 from November 6, 2010, and MyChat 7.6 (free version) from July 12, 2019.

Ability BORGChat MyChat
Installation, uninstallation and update system
1.1 Installer Yes Yes
1.2 Uninstaller Yes Yes
1.3 Automatic Installation No Yes
1.4 Automatic updating system No Yes
1.5 Automatic updating and saving of all the data when installing the latest version over the old one No new versions Yes
1.6 Portable version No Yes
Network settings
2.1 Work in large networks No Yes
2.2 Work in complex networks and via the Internet No Yes
2.3 Guaranteed message delivery No Yes
2.4 Work in terminal sessions No Yes
2.5 Traffic encryption Yes, unknown OpenSSL
2.6 Work in very bad networks (satellite connection, "long" pings) No Yes
Default functions
3.1 Private messages Yes Yes
3.2 Message statuses (received, seen) Yes, partially Yes
3.3 Text conferences Yes Yes
3.4 Notifications with a return receipt No Yes
3.5 Common Bulletin board Yes Yes
3.6 File transfer Yes Yes
3.7 Images transfer Yes Yes
3.8 Automatic backlight for links in a text Partially, except local links Yes
3.9 Messages history view Yes Yes
3.10 Event sound notification Yes Yes
3.11 Personal contact list Yes Yes
3.12 Sending messages and files to offline users No Yes
3.13 Graphic smileys Yes Yes
3.14 Voice calls Yes Yes
3.15 Video calls No Yes
3.16 Screen sharing No Yes
Active Directory integration
4.1 MSI package to deploy users via Group Policy No Yes
4.2 User transparent authorization No Yes
4.3 Importing users from the Windows domain No Yes
4.4 Support for any amount of various domains No Yes
4.5 Collaboration between common and domain users No Yes
Appearance configuration
5.1 GUI languages Yes Yes, UNICODE
5.2 Appearance customization Yes Yes
5.3 Font changing Yes Yes
6.1 Centralized configuration of user rights and restrictions No Yes
6.2 User Groups No Yes
6.3 Obscene words filter Yes Yes
6.4 IP, MAC, Hardware ID filters Yes, IP only Yes
6.5 Anti-spam and anti-flood filters No Yes
6.6 User management system No Yes, WEB interface
6.7 Detailed reference information about users (Full name, email, phone numbers, date of birth, photo, etc.) Yes, briefly Yes
Operating systems
7.1 Windows Yes Yes
7.2 Android No Yes
7.3 Linux No Yes
7.4 Mac No Yes
7.5 WEB No Yes
Additional abilities
8.1 User network status "free", "busy", "away" Yes Yes
8.2 Scripting language to write simple programs which extend chat abilities No Yes
8.3 Integration with external services No Yes (1С, phpBB, REST, php, C#, Delphi, Python, etc.)
8.4 User search system No Yes
8.5 Tree-like contact list that is common for the whole network with an unlimited nesting level No Yes
8.6 Account manager for several users who work on the same program No Yes
8.7 User ignore system Yes Yes
8.8 Plug-in system to extend program abilities Yes Yes
8.9 Company department list No Yes
8.10 Company work position list with the sorting "superiors from above" in the contact list No Yes
8.11 Built-in forum No Yes
8.12 Task management No Yes, Kanban
8.13 Website chat No Yes
8.14 Distrib Maker No Yes
Technical support
9.1 Built-in help system Yes Yes
9.2 Community support forum No Yes
9.3 Developers support via email Yes Yes
9.4 Additional reference information, articles about the program use on the website, blog, etc. No Yes
9.5 Developers support via Skype, Viber, Telegram, WhatsApp No Yes

3. Recommendations on switching to MyChat

Why? Bingo's Chat for local networks program has no updates, no problem fixes, no support for Android and iOS. There is a version for Windows only, but no software for macOS, Linux, and WEB. The application does not work in complex networks and via the Internet. No centralized server and system for users management.

How to move to MyChat? For small companies of 20 online users, such transfer from Bingo's Chat to MyChat will be easy and affordable, because the default license of MyChat is free, with no trial period (what is the difference between commercial and free MyChat versions?). MyChat is able to work "out of the box", without special settings. MyChat Free Edition updates are free. For organizations with a limited budget, it is important.

Prices. Licenses are concurrent, for the number of online users. You buy the server only. One online user costs $6. One year of updates is free, then update subscription costs $2 for one online user per year (if you want to move to new versions). Programs that are purchased individually are MyChat Guest and Distrib Maker for custom setup files, and the Quiz bot.

Support service. We provide support during the business day. Our official support forum.

How long you've been working? MyChat enterprise messenger development started in 2004; updates are stably released 5-6 times a year. More than half a million real users from Ukraine, Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, USA, Canada, India, Great Britain, etc.

Служба поддержки